Cornucopia's Plant-Based Beverage Scorecard

Last updated February 10, 2023

This scorecard includes both certified organic and conventional plant-based beverage brands. If you know of a brand not listed here, drop us a line!

Brand Name	Organic	Plant Base	Score
5-Plant RatingTop-rated plant-based beverages. Organic with few or no additives.
WestSoy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1850
Malk Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1850
Malk Oat, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Oat	1850
New Barn Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1850
EdenSoy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1850
Malk Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1850
Tofu Shop Soy, Organic Unflavored	Yes	Soy	1850
Three Trees Almond, Organic, Original	Yes	Almond	1850
Trader Joe's Soymilk, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1770
Pacific Foods Soy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1740
Willa's Oat, Organic Original	Yes	Oat	1600
Malk Oat, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1600
New Barn Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1600
Forager Soy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1600
EdenSoy, Organic, Vanilla Extra	Yes	Soy	1600
Three Trees Almond, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1600
Three Trees Almond, Organic, Black Sesame	Yes	Almond	1600
EdenSoy, Organic, Carob	Yes	Soy	1600
WestSoy, Organic, Original	Yes	Soy	1600
Three Trees Pistachio, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Pistachio/Almond	1600
Three Trees Oat, Organic, Oat and Seed	Yes	Blend	1600
Malk Oat, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Oat	1600
Kiki Oat, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Oat	1600
Kiki Oat, Organic, Original	Yes	Oat	1600
EdenSoy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1600
EdenSoy, Organic, Original Extra	Yes	Soy	1550
EdenSoy, Organic, Original	Yes	Soy	1550
New Barn Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1550
Beber Almond, Pure	Yes	Almond	1550
Tofu Shop Soy, Organic Chocolate	Yes	Soy	1550
Tofu Shop Soy, Organic Ginger	Yes	Soy	1550
Tofu Shop Soy, Organic Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1550
Rise Brewing, Organic Original	Yes	Oat	1520
Rise Brewing, Organic Chocolate	Yes	Oat	1520
Earth's Own Oat, Organic Original	Yes	Oat	1510
WestSoy, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1500
365 Almond, Organic, Original	Yes	Almond	1500
EdenSoy, Organic, Cocoa	Yes	Soy	1500
New Barn Almond, Organic, Barista	Yes	Almond	1500
Forager Cashew, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Cashew	1500
Thrive Market, Organic Almond	Yes	Almond	1500
Oatsome, Organic Original	Yes	Oat	1470
Rise Brewing, Organic Vanilla	Yes	Oat	1470
4-Plant RatingHigher-rated plant-based beverages. Organic with some additives.
Mooala Bananamilk, Organic	Yes	Banana	1450
Naturgreen Oat, Organic	Yes	Oat	1450
O Organics Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1450
GreenWise Soy, Organic, Plain	Yes	Soy	1450
Cadia Almond, Organic	Yes	Almond	1450
Mooala Bananamilk, Organic Chocolate	Yes	Banana	1450
Mooala Oat, Organic, Unsweetened Coconut	Yes	Oat	1450
Mooala Almond, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1450
Forager Oat, Organic	Yes	Oat	1450
So Delicious Coconut, Organic, Original	Yes	Coconut	1450
Mooala Almond, Organic	Yes	Almond	1450
GreenWise Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1450
O Organics Soy, Organic, Plain	Yes	Soy	1450
365 Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Coconut	1430
365 Soy Milk, Organic, Unsweetened Original	Yes	Soy	1430
Minor Figures Barista Oat, Organic	Yes	Oat	1420
Trader Joe's Rice, Organic	Yes	Rice	1420
Simple Truth Soy, Organic, Plain	Yes	Soy	1410
Simple Truth Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1410
Mooala Bananamilk, Organic, Strawberry	Yes	Banana	1400
O Organics Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1400
O Organics Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened Original	Yes	Coconut	1400
Full Circle Soy, Organic, Original	Yes	Soy	1400
O Organics Almond, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1400
O Organics Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1400
Natural By Nature Oat, Creamer	Yes	Oat	1400
Full Circle Almond, Organic, Original	Yes	Almond	1400
Natural By Nature Oat, Organic, Unsweetend	Yes	Oat	1400
Vita Coco Coconut, Organic Original	Yes	Coconut	1400
Earth's Own Soy, Organic Original	Yes	Soy	1400
Cadia Almond, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1400
SimplyNature Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1400
Natur-a Soy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1400
Pacific Foods Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1390
Pacific Foods Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Original	Yes	Almond	1390
Pacific Foods Oat, Organic, Original	Yes	Oat	1390
365 Coconut, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Coconut	1380
365 Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1380
365 Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1380
365 Soy, Organic Original	Yes	Soy	1380
Willa's Oat, Organic Creamy	Yes	Oat	1370
So Delicious Coconut, Organic Vanilla	Yes	Coconut	1350
Full Circle Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1350
So Delicious Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Coconut	1350
Full Circle Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1350
So Delicious Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Coconut	1350
Full Circle Soy, Organic, Original Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1350
Pacific Foods Oat, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Oat	1340
Pacific Foods Almond, Organic, Original	Yes	Almond	1340
Pacific Foods Almond, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1340
365 Soy Milk, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1330
365 Almond, Organic, Chocolate Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1330
365 Almond, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1330
365 Almond, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Almond	1330
Silk Almond, Organic Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1310
Simple Truth Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1310
Simple Truth Soy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1310
Silk Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1310
Silk Almond, Organic Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1310
Silk Soy, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1310
Silk Almond, Organic Original	Yes	Almond	1310
Natural By Nature Oat, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Oat	1300
Full Circle Almond, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1300
Full Circle Almond, Organic, Vanilla Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1300
Natur-a Soy, Organic, Vanilla Light	Yes	Soy	1300
Pacific Foods Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Coconut	1290
Pacific Foods Oat, Organic, Original Reduced Sugar	Yes	Oat	1290
Pacific Foods Coconut, Organic, Original	Yes	Coconut	1290
Pacific Foods Coconut, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Coconut	1290
Orgain Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1250
Elmhurst Cashew, Unsweetened	No	Cashew	1250
So Delicious Coconut, Original, Sugar Free	Yes	Coconut	1250
Elmhurst Almond, Unsweetened	No	Almond	1250
Orgain Almond, Organic, Lightly Sweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1250
Elmhurst Oat, Unsweetened	No	Oat	1250
Elmhurst Hazelnut, Unsweetened	No	Hazelnut	1250
Elmhurst Walnut, Unsweetened	No	Walnut	1250
Pacific Foods Almond, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Almond	1240
Wild Harvest Soy, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Soy	1210
Silk Soy, Organic, Vanilla Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1210
Natur-a Soy, Organic	Yes	Soy	1200
Natur-a Soy, Organic Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1200
Natur-a Soy, Organic, Cappuccino	Yes	Soy	1200
Beber Almond, Chocolate	Yes	Almond	1200
Natur-a Soy, Organic, Strawberry	Yes	Soy	1200
Sunrich Naturals Soy, Organic	Yes	Soy	1200
Natur-a Soy, Organic, Original Chocolate	Yes	Soy	1200
Beber Almond, Lavender	Yes	Almond	1200
Natur-a Soy, Organic, Original Light	Yes	Soy	1200
Beber Almond, Horchata	Yes	Almond	1200
Beber Almond, Honey Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1200
Sunrich Naturals Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1150
Natur-a Rice, Organic Original	Yes	Rice	1150
Sunrich Naturals Soy, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Soy	1150
Sunrise Soy, Unsweetened	No	Soy	1150
SimplyNature Soy, Organic, Original	Yes	Soy	1150
Pacific Foods Cashew, Made with Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Cashew	1140
Dream Rice, Organic, Original Classic	Yes	Rice	1133
Wild Harvest Soy, Organic, Original	Yes	Soy	1110
Wild Harvest Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1110
3-Plant RatingMiddle-tier plant-based beverages. A mix of organic and conventional, with additives.
Pearl Soymilk, Organic, Chocolate	Yes	Soy	1100
Pearl Soymilk, Organic, Coffee	Yes	Soy	1100
Pearl Soymilk, Organic, Original	Yes	Soy	1100
Pearl Soymilk, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Soy	1100
Pearl Soymilk, Organic, Creamy Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1100
Pearl Soymilk, Organic, Green Tea	Yes	Soy	1100
Pacific Foods Cashew, Made with Organic, Original	Yes	Cashew	1090
Dream Rice, Organic, Original Enriched	Yes	Rice	1083
Dream Soy, Organic, Original Enriched	Yes	Soy	1083
Trader Joe's Soymilk, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1070
President's Choice Almond, Organic, Unsweetened Vanilla	Yes	Almond	1050
President's Choice Almond, Organic, Unsweetened	Yes	Almond	1050
Sunrise Soy, Sweetened	No	Soy	1050
WestSoy, Organic Plus, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	1000
Natur-a Rice, Organic Vanilla	Yes	Rice	1000
WestSoy, Organic Plus, Plain	Yes	Soy	1000
Nature's Promise Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	990
Pacific Foods Soy, Ultra, Original	Yes	Soy	990
President's Choice Soy, Organic Low Fat	Yes	Soy	975
Kirkland Soy, Organic, Vanilla	Yes	Soy	966
Minor Figures Barista Oat	No	Oat	920
Kirkland Soy, Organic Plain	Yes	Soy	916
Dream Rice, Organic, Unsweetened Enriched	Yes	Rice	883
Califia Farms Oat, Original	No	Oat	850
Oat-ly Oat, Low-Fat	No	Oat	850
Dream Rice, Vanilla Classic	No	Rice	833
Trader Joe's Coconut, Unsweetened	No	Coconut	820
Kirkland Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	816
Silk Almond/Coconut, Unsweetened	No	Almond	810
Elmhurst Oat, Chocolate	No	Oat	800
Elmhurst Oat	No	Oat	800
Tempt/Living Harvest Hemp/Coconut Unsweetened	No	Blend	800
Elmhurst Cashew	No	Cashew	800
Pacific Foods Hemp, Original, Unsweetened	No	Hemp	790
Pacific Foods Hemp, Original	No	Hemp	790
Pacific Foods Hazelnut, Unsweetened Original	No	Hazelnut	790
Wild Harvest Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	760
Earth's Own Oat, Original Unsweetened	No	Oat	760
Silk Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	760
Silk Almond, Unsweetened Original	No	Almond	760
Oat-ly Oat, Original	No	Oat	750
Califia Farms "Go Coconuts" Coconut, Water Blend	No	Coconut	750
Suzie’s Quinoa, Unsweetened	No	Quinoa	750
Oat-ly Oat, Barista	No	Oat	750
2-Plant RatingLower-rated plant-based beverages. Conventional, with additives.
365 Oat, Original	No	Oat	730
Silk Cashew, Unsweetened	No	Cashew	710
Silk Soy, Chocolate	No	Soy	710
Silk Cashew, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Cashew	710
Silk Soy, Original	No	Soy	710
Silk Oat, Extra Creamy	No	Cashew	710
Silk Oat, Vanilla	No	Cashew	710
Silk Oat, Original	No	Cashew	710
Silk Soy, Vanilla	No	Soy	710
Earth's Own Cashew, Unsweetened Original	No	Cashew	710
Silk Oat, Sugar-free	No	Cashew	710
Silk Almond, Dark Chocolate	No	Almond	710
Silk Coconut, Unsweetened	No	Coconut	710
Natur-a Almond, Unsweetened	No	Almond	700
Natur-a Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	700
Full Circle Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	700
Friendly Farms Almond, Original, Unsweetened	No	Almond	700
Tempt/Living Harvest Hemp, Unsweetened Original	No	Hemp	700
Tempt/Living Harvest Hemp, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Hemp	700
Califia Farms Oat, Vanilla	No	Oat	700
Tempt/Living Harvest Hemp, Chocolate	No	Hemp	700
Nature's Promise Almond, Original, Unsweetened	No	Almond	690
Pacific Foods Hazelnut, Original	No	Hazelnut	690
Pacific Foods Hemp, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Hemp	690
Califia Farms Almond, Toasted Coconut	No	Blend	675
Trader Joe's Almond, Unsweetened Original	No	Almond	670
Wild Harvest Almond, Unsweetened Original	No	Almond	660
Simple Truth Almond, Unsweetened	No	Almond	660
Silk Almond, Less Sugar Vanilla	No	Almond	660
Earth's Own Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	660
Silk Almond, Less Sugar Original	No	Almond	660
Silk Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	660
Silk Soy, Very Vanilla	No	Soy	660
Suzie’s Quinoa, Vanilla	No	Quinoa	650
Califia Farms Almond, Unsweetened	No	Almond	650
Full Circle Almond, Original Unsweetened	No	Almond	650
Califia Farms Oat, Protein, Vanilla	No	Oat	650
Califia Farms Almond, Vanilla, Unsweetened	No	Almond	650
Califia Farms Oat, Protein, Original	No	Oat	650
Blue Diamond Almond, Original	No	Almond	650
365 Oat, Vanilla	No	Oat	630
Trader Joe's Coconut, Vanilla	No	Coconut	620
Trader Joe's Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	620
Silk Coconut, Original	No	Coconut	610
Silk Almond/Coconut, Original	No	Almond	610
Tempt/Living Harvest Hemp, Original	No	Hemp	600
Milkidamia, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Macadamia	600
Blue Diamond Almond, Unsweetened Original	No	Almond	600
Blue Diamond Almond, Banana Blend	No	Almond	600
Natur-a Almond/Coconut	No	Almond	600
Milkidamia, Unsweetened Latte	No	Macadamia	600
Milkidamia, Unsweetened	No	Macadamia	600
Tempt/Living Harvest Hemp, Original Vanilla	No	Hemp	600
Good Karma Flax Milk, Chocolate	No	Flax	600
Good Karma Flax Milk, Vanilla	No	Flax	600
Natur-a Oat, Original	No	Oat	600
Blue Diamond Almond, Hint of Honey Vanilla	No	Almond	600
Blue Diamond Almond/Coconut, Unsweetened Original	No	Blend	600
Milkidamia, Lightly Sweetened	No	Macadamia	600
Good Karma Flax, Unsweetened plus Protein	No	Flax	600
Good Karma Flax, Vanilla plus Protein	No	Flax	600
Blue Diamond Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	600
Pacific Foods Hemp, Vanilla	No	Hemp	590
Pacific Foods Hazelnut, Chocolate	No	Hazelnut	590
Dream Oat, Unsweetened	No	Oat	583
Trader Joe's Almond/Cashew/Macadamia, Unsweetened	No	Almond	570
Earth's Own Oat, Chocolate	No	Oat	560
Simple Truth Almond, Original	No	Almond	560
Earth's Own Almond, Unsweetened Original	No	Almond	560
Earth's Own Oat, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Oat	560
Earth's Own Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	560
Simple Truth Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	560
Silk Almond, Original	No	Almond	560
Full Circle Almond, Original	No	Almond	550
Oat-ly Oat, Chocolate	No	Oat	550
Califia Farms Almond, Original	No	Almond	550
Lucerne Almond, Unsweetened	No	Almond	550
Blue Diamond Almond, Chocolate	No	Almond	550
Califia Farms Almond, Barista Blend	No	Almond	550
Califia Farms Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	550
Dream Rice, Vanilla Enriched	No	Rice	533
365 Oat, Chocolate	No	Oat	530
Trader Joe's Almond, Matcha	No	Almond	520
Trader Joe's Almond, Blueberry Lavender	No	Almond	520
Trader Joe's Soymilk, Unsweetened Original	No	Soy	520
Blue Diamond Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	500
Friendly Farms Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	500
Natur-a Oat, Chocolate	No	Oat	500
Natur-a Almond, Original	No	Almond	500
Blue Diamond Almond, Reduced Sugar, Vanilla	No	Almond	500
Natur-a Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	500
Good Karma Flax Milk, Original	No	Flax	500
Natur-a Almond, Chocolate	No	Almond	500
Good Karma Plantmilk, Unsweetened	No	Oat/Flax	500
Dream Coconut, Unsweetened	No	Coconut	483
Dream Oat, Original	No	Oat	483
Simple Truth Almond, Chocolate	No	Almond	460
Earth's Own Almond, Original	No	Almond	460
Earth's Own Almond, Chocolate	No	Almond	460
Full Circle Almond, Chocolate	No	Almond	450
Full Circle Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	450
Lucerne Almond, Vanilla	No	Almond	450
Nature's Promise Almond, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Almond	440
Nature's Promise Almond, Original	No	Almond	440
Nature's Promise Almond, Original Vanilla	No	Almond	440
Dream Rice, Horchata	No	Rice	433
Simple Truth Coconut, Unsweetened	No	Coconut	410
Good Karma Plantmilk, Vanilla	No	Oat/Flax	400
Full Circle Coconut, Original Unsweetened	No	Cocunut	400
Ripple Pea, Unsweetened Vanilla	No	Pea	400
Good Karma Plantmilk, Original	No	Oat/Flax	400
Good Karma Plantmilk, Chocolate	No	Oat/Flax	400
Ripple Pea, Unsweetened Original	No	Pea	400
Dream Coconut, Vanilla Enriched	No	Coconut	383
Dream Almond, Unsweetened	No	Almond	383
1-Plant RatingLowest-rated plant-based beverages. Conventional, with additives
Lucerne Almond, Chocolate	No	Almond	350
Simple Truth Coconut, Original	No	Coconut	310
Ripple Pea, Original	No	Pea	300
Ripple Pea, Vanilla	No	Pea	300
Full Circle Coconut, Original	No	Coconut	300
Ripple Pea, Chocolate	No	Pea	300
8th Continent Soy, Original	No	Soy	0
8th Continent Soy, Vanilla	No	Soy	0

Plant-Based Beverages Scorecard

Who Owns Organic?

Seed Industry Map

GMO Labeling: Right to Know

Give a Gift

The Cultivator – Spring 2023

Organic Strikes Back

Passion Project