The USDA has strict rules regulating who can use the label, but a Dallas Morning News analysis found those standards aren’t always enforced.
By PAULA LAVIGNE
The Dallas Morning News (this link is no longer available)
More and more shoppers are forking out extra money for organic foods to avoid chemicals, eat healthy and support the environment.
But the USDA Organic label, stamped on foods as diverse as cookies, milk and mangos, may not be a mark the public can always trust.
Organic food is supposed to be free of most chemical pest killers, fertilizers, antibiotics, hormones and genetic engineering. Organic farmers and ranchers must enrich the soil and be kind to animals; chickens should strut outside and cows should regularly graze.
But a Dallas Morning News analysis has found that the United States Department of Agriculture does not know how often organic rules are broken and has not consistently taken action when potential violations were pointed out.
“The USDA has failed to enforce the regulations,” said Jim Riddle, former chairman of the National Organics Standards Board and an appointed adviser to the USDA when the organic standards were enacted in 2002.
“There have been no prosecutions of violations for the organic law yet. … They’ve failed to take action.”
Though a small slice of the overall food market, organics is growing at 16 percent a year, while overall food sales are rising only 3 percent. They are forecast to continue that pace as big grocers, most recently Wal-Mart, expand their organic offerings.
Barbara Robinson, the USDA executive who oversees the National Organic Program, said her small staff struggles to keep up with the booming industry.
“When you have eight or nine people, and everybody wants something, you try to do a little bit of everything.”
She said the label is as good as the people who are growing and monitoring the products.
“I don’t think there are any absolutes in the world anywhere. I think that’s kind of a ridiculous question,” she said.
Ms. Robinson acknowledged that the agency hasn’t fined anyone for misuse of the label, but she said certain products have been ordered to yank it.
Retailers say the label is their cue that products are authentic.
“If you buy an organic product at Wal-Mart, you can trust that it is USDA certified. But I would not be able to speak to whether those are the right standards or the wrong standards. We are retailers; we are not agronomists or scientists,” said Wal-Mart spokeswoman Gail Lavielle.
The organic program monitors at least 20,000 organic growers, ranchers, processing plants and others worldwide.
Texas looms large in organics, with more organic land than any other state. It is also home to one of the nation’s biggest organic companies, Dean Foods in Dallas, which distributes Horizon Organic dairy products and Silk soy milk. Whole Foods of Austin is the nation’s largest organic retail chain. Representatives from both companies say they take measures to make sure their products are organic.
USDA officials say the organics label is a selling point rather than a mark of nutrition. The dietary benefit of organics is the subject of debate. However, shoppers often view organic food as an investment in their health.
About 66 percent of U.S. consumers buy organic products occasionally, according to a 2004 survey by the Hartman Group, a consumer research company. Almost half said they bought organic for their health and nutrition.
Those surveyed said having children was the most significant reason to go organic, and that’s what prompted 28-year-old Megan Stewart of The Colony.
Her 1-year-old daughter was recently strapped into a shopping cart filled with organic baby food in an aisle at Whole Foods in Plano.
“I only get the USDA certified, rather than just packages that say all natural or organic,” Mrs. Stewart said. “They are really under tight regulations.”
But The News found the following reasons that organic shoppers may not be buying what they think they are:
-A review of 216 internal USDA audits shows several examples of violations at organic farms and production plants. However, reports about problems that are supposed to filter up to the agency from on-the-ground monitors are incomplete.
-Much organic food is produced overseas, where there is even less oversight. Inspectors in China, for example, describe obvious violations that are not well-tracked or known by the agency.
-Vague rules leave much to interpretation, especially when it comes to treatment of animals.
Organics is full of true believers, farmers and food processors who go above and beyond what they’re required to do. But they worry about organic scofflaws making a bad name for the whole industry.
“There’s definitely people who don’t follow the rules,” said Conner Updike, who grows organic beans and squash in central Florida. He uses chicken manure to fertilize his crops, but he’s heard that some people cut corners and use ammonium nitrate — a banned fertilizer — that costs half as much and is hard to detect.
“It’s not fair to me,” he said. “I’m trying to obey all the rules, and then someone else cheats.”
The Washington State Department of Agriculture, for example, discovered a fruit farmer who applied banned chemicals to his orchard and a mint grower selling regular mint under the organic label.
A Canadian certifier cried foul when inspectors found chickens at a Manitoba poultry producer that had no access to the outdoors, as required in organic laws.
Among 268 complaints released by the USDA, about 50 were products erroneously claiming to be organic or falsely using the label. The USDA ordered them to stop.
Problems continue to crop up, but there’s no way for the public to know how many cheaters there are.
In April, The Dallas Morning News requested records of all violations regarding individual farms, ranches and handlers. USDA officials said they could not provide the documents for at least six months.
Officials said it would take that long to collect and organize the information, though organic program rules require the USDA to make violation information available to the public on the program’s Web site. But after four years, Ms. Robinson said her staff hasn’t had time to make that happen.
The USDA does not know how many violations there are because it is missing information from those who are supposed to be policing the industry at the ground level.
The agency collects information from 56 certifiers in the United States and 40 in foreign countries, usually state-run agencies or private companies. Farms and processing plants can choose any USDA-approved certifier.
A banana from Ecuador or rice from southeast Texas can carry the USDA label only if a certifier has given approval. Certifiers hire inspectors to walk through fields, interview plant workers and comb through records. The certifiers are then supposed to notify the USDA when there are problems.
However, The Dallas Morning News reviewed hundreds of audits of certifiers that show many violations. Yet the USDA has never yanked or suspended a certifier’s accreditation, despite auditors’ recommendations to do so.
Auditors, from a separate USDA branch, wrote that certifiers approved food producers despite evidence that banned chemicals were used. Some gave approval without conducting inspections.
USDA officials would not discuss the individual audits. It’s unclear whether officials addressed problems auditors pointed out. But several audits note the same problems with the same certifiers year after year.
Inspectors, organic farmers and certifiers themselves say they know some cut corners.
Sam Welsch, owner of OneCert, a certification agency in Lincoln, Neb., said some companies hire the cheapest inspectors, not the most qualified.
“Even if one organization is doing a bad job, and a fraud issue would come up, that’s bad for the whole industry,” he said.
Big companies, such as Dean Foods, say they protect their consumers by going with reliable, trusted certifiers.
“A lot of certification agencies have been doing this for decades. I see a lot of integrity in the certifiers and think they really have been working hand in hand with the USDA,” said Kelly Shea, vice president of organic stewardship for WhiteWave Foods, a Dean Foods subsidiary.
Ms. Shea said the industry would benefit if the USDA spent more money on enforcement.
Whole Foods took another route to assure customers and is a certified organic retailer. This special status requires the chain to make sure labeled products have documents to back them up. Whole Foods also tracks food back to its producers, said Joe Dickson, the company’s organic programs coordinator.
The China connection
About 40 percent of organic farms and handlers are in foreign countries, including 300 farms and processing plants in China.
Wal-Mart used some Chinese organic soybeans in its private-label soy milk. They’ve also been in Silk, the popular soy milk brand from WhiteWave.
The United States has 2.2 million organic acres; China has 8.6 million. Almost 90 percent was certified in 2004, which raises a red flag with Mr. Riddle, who said it’s questionable that China could have transitioned farmland that quickly.
China has a history of dousing fields with chemicals, researchers say.
Fred Gale, a senior USDA economist who has researched Chinese agriculture, said it was “almost impossible to grow truly organic food in China.”
“The water everywhere is polluted, and the soil is contaminated from industry and mining, and the air is bad.”
Despite concerns about China, Ms. Robinson said the USDA is only responsible for approving the certifiers, whose job it is to check on Chinese farms or handlers.
The Organic Crop Improvement Association, a certifying agent in Lincoln, Neb., has given USDA Organic certificates to about 200 operations in China. Executive director Jeff See said his company has built trust with its producers since it started in China more than 12 years ago.
At Rizhao Huasai Foodstuffs Co., in China’s Shandong province, sales official Cui Min said workers sometimes use a fertilizer mix that includes human waste on their crops. It’s a common practice in China but a clear violation of the USDA rules.
Mr. See, whose company certified Rizhao Huasai, said workers there signed an affidavit stating they follow the rules, including those regarding fertilizers.
Simply trusting the word of a farmer might not be an adequate failsafe, said Mr. Gale, of the USDA.
In China, “there have always been laws and regulations on the books, but you find a way around them,” he said.
Mutsumi Sakuyoshi, a Japanese inspector who has checked Chinese soybean fields for many of the world’s largest certifiers, said she confronted one farm’s workers after finding an empty plastic bag of herbicide.
Workers told her wind must have blown it from a neighbor’s field.
Another farmer gave her an affidavit stating the land under inspection hadn’t been used for at least three years. Ms. Sakuyoshi found the government official who stamped it and questioned its accuracy.
“He said, ‘No. I don’t know. I don’t care. They just asked me to stamp it, so I stamped it,’ ” she said.
Mr. See said American farmers are more skeptical of Chinese organics because they’re a competitive threat to domestic producers.
“I wouldn’t say there’s probably never any problem with what OCIA has going on in China, but we find problems all around the world, even in the U.S.,” he said.
Even when standards are upheld, there are concerns throughout the industry that rules are unclear.
One of many examples is a rule that livestock must have “access to pasture.” It doesn’t say how much, for how long, or how much of a cow’s meal has to come from leisurely munching.
Big dairies, such as Aurora Organic Dairy and Horizon Organic, were criticized by activist groups for running “industrial-scale” feedlots, where they said cows rarely roamed on acres of dry, stubbly grass. Both companies insist their cows do graze and meet the requirements. Both have already added pasture.
The debate triggered boycotts and led to a lengthy discussion during the Dean Foods shareholders meeting in Dallas in May.
The National Organic Standards Board stepped in and offered more detail, including a provision that cows must be on pasture for at least 120 days each year. It’s now up to the USDA whether to make the recommendation law.
Representatives of both dairies said they support the rule’s precision.
Chris Grotegut is a farmer in the Texas Panhandle who grows corn, wheat, soybeans and other organic crops used in products distributed nationally. He said enforcing clear rules is the only way to make consumers trust the organic label.
“That is a concern … that credibility is maintained and people don’t look at [organics] as a way to turn a conventional product into a fast buck to cheat the system.”
E-mail [email protected]
When can the USDA organic seal be used?
The label is allowed on raw food and packaged products that are “100 percent organic” or “organic” from certified producers.
“Organic” products allow for up to 5 percent nonorganic ingredients. This is mainly involving materials used in processing packaged foods.
If the product is at least 70 percent organic, it cannot use the USDA seal, but it can use the phrase “made with organic ingredients.” If it is less than 70 percent, but still has some organic content, then it can only use the word “organic” to identify individual ingredients.
What is organic?
Organic food is grown without the use of most conventional pesticides, fertilizers made with synthetic ingredients, or sewage sludge. It is also not grown with bioengineering or ionizing radiation, USDA rules state. Animals are not given antibiotics or growth hormones and are supposed to have more access to the outdoors so that they can exhibit more of their natural feeding behavior. The complete rules are lengthy and vary depending on the type of operation.
Who says it’s organic?
Declarations are made by a USDA-accredited certifier, whose name should be on the product label or package.
Who are the certifiers?
The USDA has accredited 96 certifying agencies, 56 in the United States and 40 in foreign countries. Some are state agencies, such as the Texas Department of Agriculture, but most are private companies.
What do certifiers do?
They hire inspectors, whether on staff or freelance, to visit organic farms, ranches and processing plants and review operations, records and workers. The inspectors report back to the certifying agent, which determines whether the operation complies with the USDA organic rules.
Product Organic price Regular price
Raisin bran 29.3 cents per ounce 16 cents per ounce
Chicken breast $8.99 per pound $4.99 per pound
Strawberries $4.99 per pound $2.99 per pound
Baby food 21 cents per ounce 14 cents per ounce
Milk $3.50 per half gallon $2.47 per half gallon
More than 300 organic certificates have been issued to farms, ranches, processing plants and retail stores in Texas.
Whole Foods, the nation’s largest organic retail store, is headquartered in Austin.
Texas is home to one of the nation’s biggest organic companies, Dean Foods in Dallas. The company’s WhiteWave Foods subsidiary includes the best-selling organic milk brands Horizon Organic and Silk soy milk. Its competitor Aurora Organic Dairy of Boulder, Colo., operates a 4,400-cow dairy farm in Dublin, Texas.
Texas Department of Agriculture is the state’s largest certifier, granting certificates to about 70 percent of the state’s organic operations.
Texas adopted organics in 1988 when it established its own organic standards. Other states, including California and Washington, did the same before the federal regulations that went into effect in 2002.
- A company in Italy that produces butter and cheese where dairy cows are described eating organic feed not certified by the USDA
A certifier in Idaho that sent inspectors with little to no experience certifying farms, where they overlooked potential violations
A California seed company listed using synthetic fungicide — not allowed under USDA rules — in processing seeds
A brewery in Berkeley, Calif., distributing organic beer made without organic hops
Beef from a Michigan farm sold as organic though it was processed at a facility that was not organic
A Georgia company selling boxes of pecans labeled organic that contained a mix of organic and nonorganic nuts
A company in Florida selling shrimp and fish labeled as USDA-certified organic. No seafood is allowed to carry the organic label
A Michigan farm advertising beef and buffalo meat as organic, though the farm was never certified