Sassy Cow Creamery

Farm/Brand HeadquartersColumbus, WI
ProductsFluid milk
Market AreaIL, WI
Total Score1235

They write: “Sassy Cow Creamery is a farmstead milk bottling facility located near Madison, Wis. Our two dairy herds, one conventional and one organic, supply our creamery with fresh milk. Both the farms are owned and operated by brothers, James and Robert Baerwolf along with their families. They are the third generation to farm the land that their grandfather purchased in 1946.

James and Robert both graduated from UW-Madison and began dairying immediately after college. Both have all worked with dairy cattle since the time they were old enough to follow their parents around on the farm and this is where their love for cows began. It is because of this background that we place the highest value on the well-being of our animals and every farm-related decision must be good for the cows. The success of the families’ farm is directly related to how well the dairy cattle are cared for. Our families have always farmed with the cows taking center stage. We feel strongly that all aspects of Sassy Cow Creamery should be no different even the brand name conveys the attitude that it all starts with superior cows.

Our love for all dairying led us to a unique situation of having two distinct herds, traditional and organic. Our conventional herd has grown from 50 cows in the nineties to the current herd of 450 cows. These cattle live on a new farm site built in 1999 and expanded in 2003. They are milked in a parlor and housed in a sand-bedded freestall barn. During the nice times of the year, cattle are allowed to go out on grass pastures to exercise or lay in the sun.

In 2000, we recognized the growing consumer trend of interest in organic foods so we took and grew a portion of our herd using organic practices. This herd consists of 250 cows and they live just one half mile north of the Sassy Cow Creamery location. The organic cows eat a considerable part of their diet from grass on the organic pastures located on this farm.

Each milking cow is tested monthly for milk quality so we can offer the safest and highest quality products to you. Prior to the creation of our creamery, our milk was put on a truck and pooled with other farms and that was the last we ever saw of it. But having such great pride in what we produce, we decided to bring our great milk all the way to the consumer themselves, and therefore, Sassy Cow Creamery was built.”

TOTAL (possible score is 2700)1235
4-Cow Rating | Excellent
Ownership structure100Family owned business/family farm
Milk Supply80Both organic and conventional milk processed (properties kept separate)
Organic Production60Brand markets conventional and organic; processed in same creamery
Disclosure of Information for Verification100Full disclosure
Organic Certification100Midwest Organic Services Association (MOSA)
Other Labels/Standards0None
Grass-fed40Markets "pasture raised" with good grazing compliance
Soy Free Ration?No
Pasture70Fair pasture compliance
Times Milked90Two times a day (standard protocol on legitimate organic dairies)
Cull/death Rate20High cull/death rate
Replacements100Closed herd
Calves75Removed shortly after birth (standard practice)
Antibiotic Use100No antibiotic use
Hormone Usage100No hormones used
Farm Support100Staff visits farm daily
Procurement of Ingredients100No outside ingredients used
Extra Credit0None