Organic Yogurt Scorecard

Last updated December 7, 2023

Brands	Parent Company	Score
5-Spoon RatingTop rated yogurts, made with high quality milk typically from family-scale farms. Few additives, if any, included.
Hawthorne Valley, Whole Maple Vanilla	Hawthorne Valley Farm	1100
Seven Stars, Whole Vanilla	Seven Stars Farm	1100
Hawthorne Valley, Whole Plain	Hawthorne Valley Farm	1100
Radiance Dairy, Whole, Plain	Radiance Dairy	1100
Butterworks, Whole Maple	Butterworks Farm	1100
Alexandre Family Farm, Grassfed Plain	Alexandre Family Farm	1100
Butterworks, Lowfat Maple Kefir	Butterworks Farm	1100
Seven Stars, Whole Lemon	Seven Stars Farm	1100
Butterworks, Nonfat Vanilla	Butterworks Farm	1100
Butterworks, Lowfat Plain Kingdom Kefir	Butterworks Farm	1100
SpringWood, Whole Plain	Springwood Farm	1100
Butterworks, Nonfat Plain	Butterworks Farm	1100
Seven Stars, Whole Maple	Seven Stars Farm	1100
Seven Stars, Lowfat Maple	Seven Stars Farm	1100
Berle Farm, Whole Plain	Berle Farm	1100
Seven Stars, Lowfat Plain	Seven Stars Farm	1100
Butterworks, Whole Plain	Butterworks Farm	1100
Alexandre Family Farm, Vanilla	Alexandre Family Farm	1100
Seven Stars, Whole Plain	Seven Stars Farm	1100
Alexandre Family Farm, Plain	Alexandre Family Farm	1100
Clover Sonoma, Whole Greek Plain	Clover Sonoma	1000
Kalona Supernatural, Lowfat Plain	Kalona Organics	1000
Kalona Supernatural, Whole Plain	Kalona Organics	1000
Kalona Supernatural, Whole Vanilla Kefir	Kalona Organics	1000
Clover Sonoma, Nonfat Greek Plain	Clover Sonoma	1000
Stonyfield, Grassfed Greek Plain	Lactilis American Group	1000
White Mountain, Nonfat Plain	White Mountain	1000
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Plain Kefir	Clover Sonoma	1000
Maple Hill, Whole Plain Kefir	Maple Hill Creamery	1000
Stonyfield, Greek Whole Plain	Lactilis American Group	1000
White Mountain, Whole Plain	White Mountain	1000
Maple Hill, Whole Strawberry Kefir	Maple Hill Creamery	1000
Maple Hill Creamery, Whole Cream-top Vanilla	Maple Hill Creamery	1000
Butterworks, Lowfat Orange Sunshine Kefir	Butterworks Farm	1000
Maple Hill Creamery, Greek Plain	Maple Hill Creamery	1000
Stonyfield, Greek Nonfat Vanilla	Lactilis American Group	1000
Trimona, Whole Plain	Trimona	1000
Clover Sonoma, Whole Greek Honey	Clover Sonoma	1000
Butterworks, Whole Lemon	Butterworks Farm	1000
Maple Hill Creamery, Whole Cream-top Plain	Maple Hill Creamery	1000
Kalona Supernatural, Greek Plain	Kalona Organics	1000
Maple Hill, Whole Vanilla Kefir	Maple Hill Creamery	1000
Nancy's, Grassfed Whole Plain	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Whole Vanilla	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Whole Greek Plain	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Grassfed Whole Blueberry Lavender	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Grassfed Whole Vanilla	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Grassfed Whole Ginger-Peach	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Nonfat Vanilla	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Nonfat Greek Honey	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Lowfat Plain	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Nonfat Greek Plain	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Whole Greek Honey	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Nonfat Plain	Nancy's	970
Nancy's, Whole Plain	Nancy's	970
Kalona Supernatural, Whole Plain Kefir	Kalona Organics	950
Green Valley Creamery, Whole Plain Kefir	Green Valley Creamery	950
Green Valley Creamery, Lowfat Plain Kefir	Green Valley Creamery	950
Green Valley Creamery, Whole plain	Green Valley Creamery	950
Norr, Nonfat Plain	Norr	900
Norr, Whole Plain	Norr	900
Norr, Whole Black Current & Blood Orange	Norr	900
Norr, Whole Vanilla & Chamomile	Norr	900
Bellweather, Whole, Blackberry	Bellweather Farms	900
Bellweather, Whole, Vanilla	Bellweather Farms	900
Bellweather, Whole, Strawberry	Bellweather Farms	900
Bellweather, Whole, Plain	Bellweather Farms	900
Clover Sonoma, Whole Vanilla	Clover Sonoma	900
Straus Family Creamery, Lowfat Plain	Straus Family Creamery	900
Straus Family Creamery, Whole Greek Plain	Straus Family Creamery	900
Clover Sonoma, Whole Maple	Clover Sonoma	900
Liberte, Whole Coffee	General Mills	900
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Vanilla	Clover Sonoma	900
Stonyfield, Lowfat Vanilla	Lactilis American Group	900
Stonyfield, Nonfat Plain	Lactilis American Group	900
Straus Family Creamery, Whole Blueberry Pomegranate	Straus Family Creamery	900
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Plain	Clover Sonoma	900
Clover Sonoma, Whole Plain	Clover Sonoma	900
Stonyfield, Grassfed Greek Vanilla	Lactilis American Group	900
Straus Family Creamery, Nonfat Vanilla	Straus Family Creamery	900
Stonyfield, Whole Plain	Lactilis American Group	900
Straus Family Creamery, Whole Greek Vanilla	Straus Family Creamery	900
Straus Family Creamery, Lowfat Greek Plain	Straus Family Creamery	900
Maple Hill Creamery, Greek Vanilla	Maple Hill Creamery	900
Straus Family Creamery, Nonfat Plain	Straus Family Creamery	900
Straus Family Creamery, Whole Maple	Straus Family Creamery	900
Stonyfield, Lowfat Plain	Lactilis American Group	900
Stonyfield, Nonfat Vanilla	Lactilis American Group	900
Kalona Supernatural, Lowfat Vanilla	Kalona Organics	900
Straus Family Creamery, Whole Vanilla	Straus Family Creamery	900
Straus Family Creamery, Nonfat Greek Plain	Straus Family Creamery	900
Straus Family Creamery, Whole Plain	Straus Family Creamery	900
Painterland Sisters, Plain	Painterland Sister's	900
4-Spoon RatingHigher rated yogurts, usually made from high quality milk produced on family-scale farms.
Nancy's, Whole Mixed Berry	Nancy's	870
Norr, Nonfat Elderflower & Lemon	Norr	850
Norr, Nonfat Strawberry & Rhubarb	Norr	850
Norr, Nonfat Blueberry & Lavender	Norr	850
Norr, Whole Raspberry & Rosewater	Norr	850
Green Valley Creamery, Lowfat Plain	Green Valley Creamery	850
Green Valley Creamery, Lowfat Vanilla	Green Valley Creamery	850
Liberte Whole Strawberry	General Mills	800
Stonyfield, Whole Banilla	Lactilis American Group	800
Liberte, Whole Sea Salt Caramel	General Mills	800
Kalona Supernatural, Whole Vanilla	Kalona Organics	800
Liberte, Whole Mango	General Mills	800
Wallaby, Greek Whole Plain	Danone	800
Stonyfield, Nonfat Blueberry	Lactilis American Group	800
Stonyfield, Greek Whole Vanilla	Lactilis American Group	800
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Lemon	Clover Sonoma	800
Wallaby, Whole Plain	Danone	800
Stonyfield, Whole Strawberry	Lactilis American Group	800
Stonyfield, Lowfat Raspberry	Lactilis American Group	800
Stonyfield, Greek Nonfat Plain	Lactilis American Group	800
Wallaby, Greek Lowfat Plain	Danone	800
Liberte, Whole Cherry	General Mills	800
Liberte, Whole Lemon	General Mills	800
Wallaby, Greek Nonfat Plain	Danone	800
Stonyfield, Grassfed Greek Blueberry	Lactilis American Group	800
Clover Sonoma, Whole Blueberry	Clover Sonoma	800
Stonyfield, Nonfat Chocolate	Lactilis American Group	800
Liberte Whole, Lime	General Mills	800
Clover Sonoma, Whole Berry	Clover Sonoma	800
Clover Sonoma, Whole Peach	Clover Sonoma	800
Liberte, Whole Coconut	General Mills	800
Stonyfield, Lowfat Strawberry	Lactilis American Group	800
Wallaby, Lowfat Plain Kefir	Danone	800
Stonyfield, Whole Vanilla	Lactilis American Group	800
Stonyfield, Lowfat Peach	Lactilis American Group	800
Liberte, Whole Vanilla	General Mills	800
Lifeway, Whole Plain Kefir	Lifeway Foods	789
Nancy's, Whole Peach	Nancy's	770
Nancy's, Whole Strawberry Vanilla	Nancy's	770
Green Valley Creamery, Lowfat Strawberry	Green Valley Creamery	750
Painterland Sisters, Blueberry Lemon	Painterland Sister's	750
Painterland Sisters, Strawberry	Painterland Sister's	750
Painterland Sisters, Vanilla Bean	Painterland Sister's	750
Painterland Sisters, Savannah's Peach	Painterland Sister's	750
Lifeway, Lowfat Plain Kefir	Lifeway Foods	739
Clover Sonoma, Whole Greek Vanilla	Clover Sonoma	700
Earth's Best, Peach Banana Smoothie	Hain Celestial	700
Clover Sonoma, Whole Greek Blueberry	Clover Sonoma	700
Clover Sonoma, Whole Strawberry	Clover Sonoma	700
Earth's Best, Pear Mango Smoothie	Hain Celestial	700
Clover Sonoma, Whole Greek Raspberry	Clover Sonoma	700
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Strawberry	Clover Sonoma	700
Earth's Best, Strawberry Banana Smoothie	Hain Celestial	700
Earth's Best, Apple Blueberry Smoothie	Hain Celestial	700
Earth's Best, Mixed Berry Smoothie	Hain Celestial	700
Earth's Best, Pineapple Orange Banana Smoothie	Hain Celestial	700
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Berry	Clover Sonoma	700
Wallaby, Whole Key Lime	Danone	700
3-Spoon RatingMiddle tier yogurt that may be made from low rated organic milk and/or include additives.
Lifeway, Whole Lemon Kefir	Lifeway Foods	689
Lifeway, Whole Coconut Honey Kefir	Lifeway Foods	689
Green Valley Creamery, Lowfat Blueberry	Green Valley Creamery	650
Painterland Sisters, Meadow Berry	Painterland Sister's	650
Lifeway, Lowfat Blueberry Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Whole Peach Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Lowfat Strawberry Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Whole Mixed Berry Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Whole Strawberry Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Lowfat Peach Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Lowfat Raspberry Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Lifeway, Lowfat Pomegranate Acai Kefir	Lifeway Foods	639
Wallaby, Greek Whole Vanilla	Danone	600
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Peach	Clover Sonoma	600
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Blueberry	Clover Sonoma	600
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Summer Strawberry Kefir	Clover Sonoma	600
Wallaby, Lowfat Vanilla Kefir	Danone	600
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Perfect Blueberry Kefir	Clover Sonoma	600
Wallaby, Lowfat Mango Kefir	Danone	600
O Organics, Nonfat Greek Plain	Safeway/Albertson's	600
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Mango Passionfruit Pineapple Kefir	Clover Sonoma	600
Clover Sonoma, Lowfat Pomegranate Strawberry Acai Kefir	Clover Sonoma	600
Wallaby, Whole Vanilla	Danone	600
Wallaby, Greek Whole Blueberry	Danone	600
Wallaby, Whole Raspberry	Danone	600
Clover Sonoma, Nonfat Greek Vanilla	Clover Sonoma	600
Horizon, Whole Plain	Danone	600
365 Everyday, Nonfat Plain	Whole Foods/Amazon	550
Simple Truth, Nonfat Greek Plain	Kroger	550
Green Valley Creamery, Lowfat Blueberry Pomegranate Acai Kefir	Green Valley Creamery	550
365 Everyday, Whole Greek Plain	Whole Foods/Amazon	550
Latta, Nonfat Plain	Latta USA	533
Latta, Acidophilus Plain	Latta USA	533
Pavel's, Lowfat Plain	Pavel's	520
Wegman's, Whole Greek Plain	Wegman's	520
Green Mountain Creamery, Lowfat Greek Plain	Green Valley Creamery	507
Wallaby, Greek Whole, No Sugar Added Vanilla Chai	Danone	500
Wallaby, Greek Whole, No Sugar Added Peach Hibiscus	Danone	500
Wallaby, Lowfat Blueberry Kefir	Danone	500
Wallaby, Whole Strawberry	Danone	500
Wallaby, Lowfat Strawberry Kefir	Danone	500
O Organics, Whole Plain	Safeway/Albertson's	500
Wallaby, Greek Whole, No Sugar Added Strawberry Rose	Danone	500
Wallaby, Greek Whole Raspberry	Danone	500
Wallaby, Greek Whole Strawberry	Danone	500
365 Everyday, Whole Vanilla	Whole Foods/Amazon	450
Simple Truth, Lowfat Plain	Kroger	450
365 Everyday, Whole Plain	Whole Foods/Amazon	450
365 Everyday, Lowfat Plain	Whole Foods/Amazon	450
2-Spoon RatingLower rated brands, typically made from factory farm milk or from milk of unknown origin.
Latta, Nonfat Vanilla	Latta USA	433
Horizon, Whole Vanilla	Danone	400
O Organics, Nonfat Greek Vanilla	Safeway/Albertson's	400
365 Everyday, Lowfat Vanilla	Whole Foods/Amazon	400
Latta, Nonfat Peach	Latta USA	383
365 Everyday, Whole Blueberry	Whole Foods/Amazon	350
Wegman's, Lowfat Plain	Wegman's	320
Horizon, Whole Strawberry	Danone	300
Wegman's, Nonfat Greek Vanilla	Wegman's	270
Wegman's, Nonfat Greek Blueberry	Wegman's	270
Simple Truth, Lowfat Vanilla	Kroger	250
365 Everyday, Whole Strawberry	Whole Foods/Amazon	250
Simple Truth, Nonfat Greek Vanilla Bean	Kroger	250
1-Spoon RatingLowest rated yogurts, typically made from factory farm milk or from milk of unknown origin.
Wegman's, Whole Strawberry Banana	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Whole Mixed Berry	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Lowfat Vanilla	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Lowfat Blueberry	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Lowfat Black Cherry	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Lowfat Peach	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Whole Vanilla	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Lowfat Raspberry	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Nonfat Greek Strawberry	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Lowfat Strawberry	Wegman's	220
Wegman's, Nonfat Greek Black Cherry	Wegman's	220
4-Spoon RatingHigher rated yogurts, usually made from high quality milk produced on family-scale farms.
Lifeway Skyr, Wildberries	Lifeway Foods	0
Lifeway Skyr, Blueberry	Lifeway Foods	0

Who Owns Organic?

Seed Industry Map

GMO Labeling: Right to Know

Give a Gift

New tool helps eaters avoid mega companies when stocking their pantry

Cornucopia to Investigate Allegations of Animal Abuse at a Horizon Dairy Farm in Texas

National Organic Standards Board Fall Meeting Recap