Product NameRatingCertified OrganicParent CompanyScore
5-Spoon RatingTop-rated cottage cheese. Organic, made with high-quality milk, and few or no additives.
Dutch Meadows A2A2YesDutch Meadows Organic Dairy2150
Kalona Super Natural 4%YesKalona Supernatural2050
Kalona Super Natural 2% Reduced FatYesKalona Supernatural2050
Nancy's Whole MilkYesNancy's2025
Nancy's Organic Probiotic Low FatYesNancy's2025
Good Culture Organic Whole MilkYesGood Culture1995
Westby Organic Small Curd 4%YesWestby Creamery1983
4-Spoon RatingHigher-rated cottage cheese. Organic, but either made with lower-rated milk or includes additives, or both.
Organic Valley 2% Low FatYesOrganic Valley1650
Organic Valley 4%YesOrganic Valley1650
Good Culture Organic PineappleYesGood Culture1645
Good Culture Organic Bluebarry Acai ChiaYesGood Culture1645
Good Culture Organic MangoYesGood Culture1645
Good Culture Organic Strawberry ChiaYesGood Culture1645
365 Low Fat 1.5%YesWhole Foods1550
365 4%YesWhole Foods1550
Clover Organic 1.5%YesClover Sonoma1350
Clover Organic 2% Low FatYesClover Sonoma1350
Horizon Regular Small Curd 4%YesDanone1350
3-Spoon RatingMiddle-tier cottage cheese. Conventional, with few or no additives.
Nancy's Natural Probiotic Low FatNoNancy's1225
Good Culture 2%NoGood Culture1095
Daisy 4%NoDaisy Brands1050
Daisy Low-fatNoDaisy Brands1050
Horizon Low FatYesDanone1050
2-Spoon RatingLower-rated cottage cheese. Conventional, with additives.
Good Culture 4%NoGood Culture845
Muuna Plain Low FatNoBright Food700
Muuna Classic 4%NoBright Food700
Friendship Pot Style 2%NoSaputo Dairy Foods600
Knudsen Fat FreeNoKraft600
Trader Joes Fat FreeNoTrader Joes600
Breakstone's 2%NoKraft600
Knudsen 2%NoKraft600
Breakstone's 4%NoKraft600
Knudsen Small Curd 4%NoKraft600
Friendship California Style 4%NoSaputo Dairy Foods600
Good Culture Blueberry 2%NoGood Culture545
Breakstone's Fat FreeNoKraft500
Breakstone's Small Curd 2%NoKraft500
Muuna VanillaNoBright Food500
Lactaid 4%NoHP Hood500
Dairy Pure Mix-in PineappleNoFormerly Dean Foods/TBD500
Breakstone's Small Curd 2%, 30% less sodiumNoKraft500
Good Culture Strawberry 2%NoGood Culture445
Good Culture Pineapple 2%NoGood Culture445
Good Culture Peach 2%NoGood Culture445
1-Spoon RatingLowest-rated cottage cheese. Conventional, with additives
Market Pantry 4%NoTarget400
Dairy Pure Mix-in BlueberryNoFormerly Dean Foods/TBD400
Dairy Pure Mix-in Strawberry & AlmondNoFormerly Dean Foods/TBD400
Dairy Pure Mix-in Peach & PecanNoFormerly Dean Foods/TBD400
Friendship Strawberry 1%NoSaputo Dairy Foods400
Market Pantry Fat FreeNoTarget400
Muuna MangoNoBright Food400
Knudsen Pineapple Low fatNoKraft400
Market Pantry 1%NoTarget400
Westby Large CurdNoWestby Creamery333
Friendship No Salt Added 1%NoSaputo Dairy Foods300
Muuna PeachNoBright Food300
Breakstone's RaspberryNoKraft300
Friendship Pineapple 1%NoSaputo Dairy Foods300
Muuna StrawberryNoBright Food300
Breakstone's Mango HabaneroNoKraft300
Muuna RaspberryNoBright Food300
Friendship Whipped 1%NoSaputo Dairy Foods300
Breakstone's BlueberryNoKraft300
Friendship Peach 1%NoSaputo Dairy Foods300
Friendship Small Curd 1% LowfatNoSaputo Dairy Foods300
Trader Joes Small Curd 4%NoTrader Joes300
Muuna Pineapple 2%NoBright Food300
Muuna Black CherryNoBright Food300
Breakstone's PineappleNoKraft300
Breakstone's Honey VanillaNoKraft300
Breakstone's PeachNoKraft300
Breakstone's StrawberryNoKraft300
Muuna BlueberryNoBright Food300
Westby Small Curd 2%NoWestby Creamery233
Westby Small Curd Low-FatNoWestby Creamery233
Westby Fat-FreeNoWestby Creamery233
Land O'Lakes Large Curd 4%NoLand O'Lakes200
Great Value Small Curd 1%NoWal-Mart200
Great Value Small Curd 4%NoWal-Mart200
Land O'Lakes Small Curd 1%NoLand O'Lakes200
Land O'Lakes Small Curd 4%NoLand O'Lakes200
Cabot 4%NoAgri-Mark Cooperative200
Land O'Lakes Small Curd Fat FreeNoLand O'Lakes200
Kemps Small Curd 4%NoDairy Farmers of America200
Publix Small CurdNoPublix200
Kemps Large CurdNoDairy Farmers of America200
Land O'Lakes Small Curd 2%NoLand O'Lakes200
Great Value Large Curd 4%NoWal-Mart200
Publix Large CurdNoPublix200
Kemps w/ Chives 4%NoDairy Farmers of America200
Cabot No FatNoAgri-Mark Cooperative200
Kemps PeachNoDairy Farmers of America100
Borden 1%NoDairy Farmers of America100
Publix Fat FreeNoPublix100
Publix Low FatNoPublix100
Kemps 1%NoDairy Farmers of America100
Borden Large Curd 4%NoDairy Farmers of America100
Kemps PineappleNoDairy Farmers of America100
Harris Teeter Small Curd Fat FreeNoKroger100
Kemps 2%NoDairy Farmers of America100
Borden Fat-FreeNoDairy Farmers of America100
Kemps Fat FreeNoDairy Farmers of America100
Kemps Honey PearNoDairy Farmers of America100
Kemps StrawberryNoDairy Farmers of America100
Borden Small Curd 4%NoDairy Farmers of America100
Kemps Mixed BerryNoDairy Farmers of America0
Friendship Pineapple 0%NoSaputo Dairy Foods0
Friendship Small Curd 0%NoSaputo Dairy Foods0
Great Value Small Curd Fat FreeNoWal-Mart0

Give a Gift

The Cornucopia Institute, through research and investigations on agriculture and food issues, provides needed information to family farmers, consumers and other stakeholders in the good food movement and to the media.

Stay Engaged

Sign up for The Cornucopia Institute’s eNews and action alerts to stay informed about organic food and farm issues.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.